Teaching resources · Animal behavior
Honeybee house hunting
A honeybee swarm has to choose a new home. Change the number and quality of nest sites and see how scouts reach a group decision.
Created by Jessie Ebie and Ted Pavlic.
About the activity
Based on Thomas Seeley’s research on how honeybee swarms choose a nest site, this agent-based model lets students form hypotheses, design experiments, collect data, and interpret results during class, even in a large lecture with no lab. I developed it with Ted Pavlic to teach group decision-making and social behavior in a 170-student animal behavior course, and later adapted the activity for the first day of introductory biology to review the scientific process.
When a honeybee colony gets crowded in late spring, the old queen leaves with thousands of workers. The swarm hangs from a branch while a few hundred scouts search for a new home, usually a hollow in a tree. Scouts that find a promising site come back and dance to recruit others, and they dance longer for better sites. More bees visit the best sites, and once enough of them gather at one site, the whole swarm flies there. No single bee compares every option. The choice comes from the group.
That makes it a good system for talking about why animals live in groups: a swarm can make a better decision than any one bee could, but the decision takes time, and a slow decision has costs of its own.
Learning objectives
- Compare and contrast the costs and benefits of group living
- Develop a hypothesis or prediction and design an experiment
- Interpret data to explain group decision-making in social animals
Below the model: how it works, what each control does, and things to try.
Try the model
An interactive NetLogo Web model. Press setup, then go. It takes a few seconds to load. On a phone, open the model in its own tab for more room.
How the model works
The swarm hangs in the gray circle in the middle. About one bee in ten is a scout. Scouts fly out and search for the three possible nest sites, shown as blue, orange, and green circles numbered 1 to 3.
A scout that finds a site flies back and recruits other bees, and it recruits for longer when the site is better. Recruited bees fly out to that site. If too few bees are there, they eventually return to the swarm, and some of them scout again. Once enough bees are at one site at the same time (the quorum), the whole swarm, queen included, moves there. The queen is the bee with the crown.
Choose your settings, press setup, then press go. The plot shows how many bees are at each site over time.
The controls
population- How many bees are in the swarm, from 1 to 500. Bigger swarms need more bees at a site to reach a quorum.
nest1-quality-numbertonest3-quality-number- How good each site is, from 0 to 5.
nest1-distancetonest3-distance- How far each site is from the swarm: near, far, or very far. Distance changes each site’s actual quality, shown in the monitors, so students can test how quality and distance trade off.
- quorum and ticks quorum reached monitors
- How many bees a site needs, and how long the swarm took to get there. This is how long the decision took.
bee-id?- Labels each bee with a number, so you can follow one bee through the whole decision.
Things to try
- Make all three sites the same quality and distance. Which site does the swarm choose? Run it several times. Is it always the same one?
- Make one site clearly better than the others. Does the swarm pick it? How long does the decision take?
- Make two sites nearly equal. Does the decision take longer? Does the swarm ever choose the worse site?
- Change the size of the swarm. Do bigger swarms decide faster, or more accurately?
Before each run, write down a hypothesis and a prediction. Then change one setting at a time, and run each setting several times so your class can pool its data.
What students should see
Swarms usually choose the best site, and they decide fastest when one site stands out. When sites are close in quality, decisions take longer and the swarm sometimes settles on the weaker site, which opens a discussion of the trade-off between speed and accuracy in group decisions.
For instructors
- Google Form for class data entry An example of the format. Make your own copy for your class.
- Sample data Opens a copy in your own Google Drive.
Model © 2012 Jessica Ebie and Theodore Pavlic, based on Seeley (1989) and Seeley and Buhrman (1999, 2001). Licensed CC BY-NC-SA 3.0.